New York’s Waterways Are Swimming in Plastic Microbeads

August 16, 2017
Toothpaste, soap, sunscreen and other everyday products often contain microbeads, which wash unfiltered into nearby waters. Here, water drains into Newtown Creek.

Toothpaste, soap, sunscreen and other everyday products often contain microbeads, which wash unfiltered into nearby waters. Here, water drains into Newtown Creek, a heavily polluted channel that divides Brooklyn and Queens.

It’s morning. Brush your teeth. A quick shower, shampoo. Going to the beach? Get on the sunscreen. OK, ready to roll. You’ve just sent countless microscopic plastic bits swirling down the drain, through the sewer system and into the nearest water body.

Many common products including toothpastes, cosmetics, shampoos, soaps and sunscreens contain tiny plastic spheres. The ball-bearing effect of these so-called microbeads gives products their smooth feel and spreadability. Introduced in the 1990s, they are too small for sewage plants to filter out, so they go straight to rivers, lakes and oceans. Here, pesticides, drugs and industrial compounds like PCBs tend to glom onto their surfaces. Zooplankton, fish and shellfish eat them. They are building up in the environment, adding to the burden of plastic bits that result from the breakdown of larger objects like plastic bottles, bags and other items that potentially threaten ecosystems and human health.

Aboard a vessel run by the environmental group Riverkeeper, oceanographer Joaquim Goes of Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory (left) and PhD. student Ye Li filter water from New York harbor. They were on a mission to study the prevalence of plastic microbeads. (Photos: Kevin Krajick, unless otherwise credited.)

Aboard a vessel run by the environmental group Riverkeeper, oceanographer Joaquim Goes of Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory (left) and PhD. student Ye Li filter water from New York harbor. They were on a mission to study the prevalence of plastic microbeads in area waters. (Photos: Kevin Krajick, unless otherwise credited.)

Barnard College student Shelly Lim drags a net through the waters of Newtown Creek, bordering Queens and Brooklyn.

Barnard College student Shelly Lim drags a net through Newtown Creek.

While many researchers have been studying pollution resulting from larger objects, scientists at Columbia University’s Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory are now doing what may be the first assessment of microbeads in waters around New York City. By one estimate, some 19 tons of them are flushed into the water each year. The effort is led by marine biologist Joaquim Goes and geochemist Beizhan Yan. Goes got interested last year, when he took water samples that turned up huge concentrations of microbeads off South Korea, a major manufacturer of cosmetics. He then examined existing water samples from as far off as the Arctic Ocean and found them there too. He and Yan decided to investigate near home.

Lamont-Doherty geochemist Beizhan Yan (left) and Goes inspect images of tiny debris generated in real time by an experimental apparatus.

Lamont-Doherty geochemist Beizhan Yan (left) and Goes inspect images of tiny debris generated in real time by an experimental apparatus.

Glowing particles in this microscope image are plastic particles; spherical ones like the one at upper left are plastic microbeads. (Joaquim Goes)

Glowing particles in this microscope image are plastics; spherical ones like the one at upper left are plastic microbeads. (Joaquim Goes)

One recent summer day, Goes, Yan and two Columbia students boarded a 36-foot vessel operated by Riverkeeper, a nonprofit that works to conserve the Hudson River and nearby waters. Captain John Lipscomb picked them up near Lamont-Doherty, along the river’s east bank just north of Manhattan. Working their way downriver, they stopped several times to sample water and sediments. By afternoon, they were in New York harbor just off the Statute of Liberty. Wakes from big ferries and cargo ships rocked the little vessel from multiple directions. They dipped a fine-mesh plankton net into the waves and filtered the water in it into a quart jar for later analysis. They dropped a little steam-shovel-type scoop to grab a sample of the mucky bottom. Goes was also testing a new flowmeter that sucks surface water through tubing into an analyzer that sorts out floating particles by shape, displaying them in real time on a screen. Amid the irregular bits of junk, many with the telltale spherical shape of microbeads flashed by on the screen.

Now-defunct factories like this one on the Brooklyn side of the East River introduced a panoply of earlier pollutants to city waters. Plastics are a newer problem.

Now-defunct factories like this one on the Brooklyn side of the East River introduced a panoply of earlier pollutants to city waters. Plastics are a newer problem.

Along Newtown Creek, a crane loads recycled plastics onto a barge. Microbeads are only part of the pollution stream; larger objects often end up in the water by one route or another, where they break down into small bits.

Along Newtown Creek, a crane loads recycled plastics onto a barge. Microbeads are only part of the pollution stream; larger objects often end up in the water by one route or another, where they break down into small bits.

Lipscomb rounded the tip of Manhattan and headed up the East River, under the Brooklyn Bridge, and toward Newtown Creek. The creek—actually now more a walled-in open sewer—divides Brooklyn and Queens, and is lined with the remains of defunct factories, oil refineries and toxic waste dumps, along with operating scrapyards and other industrial facilities. It is one of the most polluted places in the United States. Here, the flowmeter went crazy.

Captain John Lipscomb hauls a scoop of muck from the bottom of Newtown Creek.

Captain John Lipscomb hauls a scoop of muck from the bottom of Newtown Creek.

Yan samples the muck. It will go back to the lab for analysis.

Yan samples the muck. It will go back to the lab for analysis.

A few weeks after the cruise, inspections by microscope showed that water from each of the boat’s seven stops were loaded with plastics. Many appeared to be eroded bits and fibers of larger items—remains of carpets, clothing, food packaging, paints—but among them were also apparent microbeads.  Plastics from Newtown Creek carried heavy doses of atlenol, a drug used to treat high blood pressure. (“People in that neighborhood must be under a lot of stress,” quipped Goes. “Soon maybe we’ll learn other things about them.”) Testing has only begun; Goes says further analysis will probably turn up other pollutants sticking to plastics, and allow the team to estimate the quantity of microbeads versus other plastics.

In Goes's lab, high-school students Roman Louw (at microscope)) and Reaan Sarker (far left) examine samples. (Kim Martineau)

In Goes’s lab, high-school students Roman Louw (at microscope) and Reaan Sarker (far left) examine samples. (Kim Martineau)

High school science teacher Debra Magadini holds a jar of fish cfrom a marsh near Lamont. Students will analyze their guts for plastics, including microbeads. (Kim Martineau)

High school science teacher Debra Magadini holds a jar of fish from a marsh near Lamont. Students will analyze their guts for plastics, including microbeads. (Kim Martineau)

This summer, three high-school students and a teacher worked at Lamont with Goes on a related project to study the gut contents of small fish taken from a nearby riverside marsh. Preliminary results suggest they also contain microbeads and other plastics. Goes’s lab is helping them do the analyses.

A tug moves an empty barge up Newtown Creek.

A tug moves an empty barge up Newtown Creek.

The problem probably will not abate much any time soon. A federal law passed in 2015 outlaws plastic microbeads in rinse-off cosmetics, and about a dozen states have followed suit. But these laws do not cover most other products, and most do not take effect until 2018. A few large manufacturers of soaps and related products have started phasing out plastic microbeads voluntarily in favor of biodegradable substitutes. Meanwhile, say Goes and Yan, it is important simply to figure out what’s already in the water.

Media Inquiries: 
Kevin Krajick
kkrajick@ei.columbia.edu
(212) 854-9729